Imagine tuning into Jeopardy and catching a category titled “Potential Options to Replace Juan Soto in the Yankees Outfield.” Suddenly, a question pops up: “No.” The buzzer sounds, and the correct answer is, “Who Is Alex Verdugo?” This scenario, while humorous, encapsulates the initial reaction and subsequent questions surrounding the New York Yankees’ acquisition of Alex Verdugo in December 2023. But who exactly is Alex Verdugo, and why did the Yankees trade for him?
Back in the 2023 season, the Yankees’ outfield was in dire need of reinforcement. Their primary need was to acquire not one, but two capable MLB outfielders. While landing Juan Soto was a clear priority, the Yankees still needed to address the left field position, preventing a repeat of situations where players like Oswaldo Cabrera filled the role. To address this, the Yankees engaged in a trade with a familiar rival, the Boston Red Sox. The Red Sox, looking to move on from assets acquired in the Mookie Betts trade, sent Alex Verdugo to the Bronx to take over left field duties.
Instead of delving deep into statistical analyses, which have been extensively covered elsewhere, let’s focus on understanding the essence of Alex Verdugo’s performance and role. For a detailed look at his stats, resources like last month’s report card on Pinstripe Alley provide comprehensive data. However, to truly grasp the Alex Verdugo experience, consider this play:
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/73027527/1428466457.0.jpg)
This play, though painful as it represents a World Series loss at home, is illustrative of Verdugo’s season with the Yankees. He was brought in to provide a reliable outfield presence, allowing the Yankees to avoid rushing top prospects like Jasson Domínguez. While his performance might have been seen as inconsistent at times, he fulfilled this primary objective and even delivered some crucial hits during the Yankees’ journey to the World Series. However, the perception remained that he didn’t consistently deliver in high-pressure situations, particularly in the latter half of the season.
Does this mean the trade was a mistake? Not necessarily. Verdugo’s .233/.291/.356 slash line was undeniably below his career standards, significantly impacted by a period following his collision with the outfield wall. It’s reasonable to expect a better performance from him. Yet, even at his peak, Verdugo projects as a league-average hitter with solid corner outfield defense and the versatility to play center field when needed. A year prior to the trade, this skillset was precisely what the Yankees needed in left field.
However, the landscape has shifted. With Juan Soto now part of the Yankees’ roster, the team’s outfield needs have evolved. The focus has turned towards acquiring an “impact bat” to further bolster their offensive lineup. Players like Anthony Santander and Teoscar Hernández represent potential upgrades in this area. Cody Bellinger, with his left-handed power and the short right-field porch at Yankee Stadium, could also be an impactful addition. Even a player of Kyle Tucker’s caliber, reportedly available from the Astros, would fit this need for a significant offensive contributor.
While Alex Verdugo could theoretically rebound and improve upon his 2023 performance, the Yankees’ current aspirations likely require more than what he offers. Unless Verdugo is willing to transition into a role as a fourth outfielder and a bat off the bench, his future may lie elsewhere. The Yankees are now aiming for outfielders who can be game-changers, not just steady contributors.
