Alex Cooper, the personality behind the incredibly popular podcast Call Her Daddy, recently made headlines beyond her usual media circles. She stepped onto the hallowed ground of Fenway Park to throw out the first pitch at a Boston Red Sox game. While this might seem like a standard celebrity appearance, for Cooper, it was a return to a past intertwined with Boston’s beloved baseball team – a past that includes a rumored relationship with a Red Sox player, famously known as ‘Red Sox Man’.
Cooper, who transitioned from a Barstool Sports podcaster to building her own podcasting empire with Call Her Daddy, is no stranger to the spotlight. However, it’s her connection to the Red Sox that has piqued the interest of many, especially after she recounted tales of dating a player from the team that clinched the 2013 World Series title. This revelation made her appearance at Fenway Park more than just a ceremonial pitch; it was a nostalgic homecoming with a dash of intrigue.
Before her recent marriage to movie producer Matt Kaplan and long before her podcasting fame, Alex Cooper was a student at Boston University and, according to her stories, romantically involved with a player from the celebrated 2013 Red Sox team. She has referred to this individual as ‘Red Sox Man’, keeping his identity shrouded in mystery. This anonymity has only fueled speculation and curiosity, especially among her dedicated fanbase, the “Daddy Gang,” and Boston sports enthusiasts alike.
According to Cooper’s narrative, the relationship began passionately. As a sophomore in college, she found herself in a whirlwind romance with this unnamed Red Sox player. She described initial “sleepovers” and the excitement of dating someone connected to the city’s triumphant baseball team. However, the relationship wasn’t destined for the long haul. Cooper has indicated that the romance cooled off, and they eventually parted ways, with the definitive end coming around the time he was traded in 2015.
This timeline and the details shared by Cooper have led to widespread internet sleuthing to uncover the identity of ‘Red Sox Man’. Among the names thrown into the ring, one stands out prominently: Mike Napoli. Napoli was indeed a key player for the 2013 Red Sox, known for his iconic beard and impactful performance during their World Series run. He also fits the timeline, having been traded from the Red Sox in 2015.
The internet conjecture around Mike Napoli being ‘Red Sox Man’ is not without its merits. As one commenter pointed out, “It’s Mike Napoli. He got traded in 2015, his salary was 16 mil in those 2 years, and he’s got a beard.” Another online detective elaborated, “I know nothing about baseball but I did some detective work, beard? ✅salary in 2014&2015 16 million? ✅13 years older than Alex ? ✅Got traded in 2015? ✅I think Mike is our boy.” These pieces of circumstantial evidence have solidified Mike Napoli as the prime suspect in the ‘Red Sox Man’ mystery for many online.
While Alex Cooper has not confirmed or denied the identity of ‘Red Sox Man’, the speculation adds an intriguing layer to her personal history and her recent return to Fenway Park. Whether it is Mike Napoli or another player from that era, the mystery of ‘Red Sox Man’ continues to fascinate, blending the worlds of sports, celebrity gossip, and podcast culture. The story serves as a reminder of the personal lives behind the athletes we cheer for and the enduring appeal of a good, old-fashioned mystery.
